The Deadly Tobacco Drug War Down Under
by Jacob Grier, Reason, June 17, 2024.
Excerpt:
Since March of last year, the Australian state of Victoria has been rocked by a series of arsons and firebombings. Some of the targets are victims of extortion; others are caught in an escalating turf war between rival gangs. Two men with links to organized crime have been publicly murdered, one in a broad-daylight shooting at a shopping mall in a Melbourne suburb. Violent conflict is not unexpected in organized crime, but what is unusual is the drug at the center of this conflict: nicotine.
DRH comment: The Australian government could respond by getting rid of the regulations that led to the problem in the first place, but instead decides to go the Saudi route:
A new bill expected to pass the Australian Senate would take even more drastic measures, threatening imprisonment for importing, manufacturing, supplying, or even possessing commercial quantities of vaping goods without authorization. Health Minister Mark Butler explained that penalties will include up to seven years imprisonment and fines up to $2.2 million. “We are serious about stamping this public health menace of recreational vaping out,” said Butler. The bill includes an exemption for personal use, but as it is currently written possession of even noncommercial quantities of vaping products could be punished with up to one year in prison.
Fauci Was Just a Symptom
By Jeffrey H. Anderson, Thomas D. Klingenstein, June 20, 2024.
HHS now brazenly asserts that PEPFAR has saved “over 25 million lives.” The sole basis for this dubious claim seems to be that over 25 million people (counting babies in the womb) have been given antiviral drugs. HHS’s apparent dual assumption is that every one of those people would have died without the drugs, and every one of them has subsequently survived because of the drugs. This is what passes for scientific rigor at HHS.
Both during AIDS and during Covid-19, Fauci and company fought the use of inexpensive, repurposed drugs to help people’s immune systems fight off the threats. Kennedy argues that they were motivated by a desire to bring pharmaceutical products to market—both antivirals and vaccines—without facing cheap competition, as a portion of Big Pharma’s profits would make their way into the public health officials’ pockets. Indeed, NBC News reports that NIH researchers have personally collected up to $150,000 a year in royalty payments for drugs they have helped develop at taxpayer expense. NBC says that in 2004 NIH researchers pocketed a total of $8.9 million. That’s in addition to their taxpayer-funded salaries. More recently, royalties from Covid vaccines appear to have been quite a boon to NIH, as in 2022 the agency’s overall royalties (not just the portion paid out to employees) skyrocketed to nine times what they were in the pre-Covid year of 2019.
Rather than debate Duesberg or provide persuasive evidence to debunk him, the public health establishment simply ostracized him. Kennedy writes that both Larry King and Good Morning America scheduled joint appearances with Fauci and Duesberg only to cancel on Duesberg at the last minute and give Fauci the stage to himself (presumably at Fauci’s insistence). He writes that, when Reagan wanted the two to have a “friendly debate” in front of him, the idea was called off because, in the words of a member of the Reagan administration, Fauci “threw a ‘small fit’…and demanded to know why the White House was interfering in scientific matters.” (Imagine the gall of a president wanting an executive branch employee to defend his theory on one of the most pressing issues of the day!)
DRH note: My quoting from this review does NOT mean that I endorse everything that RFK Jr. says. I do think that he and the reviewer have good insights.
Federal Budget Deficit Forecast Jumps $400 Billion, Fueled by Student Debt Forgiveness
by Emma Camp, Reason, June 21, 2014.
Excerpt:
In 2024, the federal budget deficit is estimated to reach nearly $2 trillion, according to new projections released by the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) this week. In February, the agency predicted that the deficit would only be $1.58 trillion. However, spending increases have caused the projected deficit to increase by $400 billion, a staggering 27 percent hike.
According to the CBO, 80 percent of the spike in the deficit can be blamed on four sources of government spending.
The largest source, responsible for $145 billion of the increase, is changes to the federal student loan program that have resulted in massive waves of federal student loan forgiveness and increased forgiveness going forward.
How 3M Executives Convinced a Scientist the Forever Chemicals She Found in Human Blood Were Safe
by Sharon Lerner, ProPublica, May 20, 2024.
Excerpt:
Kris Hansen had worked as a chemist at the 3M Corporation for about a year when her boss, an affable senior scientist named Jim Johnson, gave her a strange assignment. 3M had invented Scotch Tape and Post-it notes; it sold everything from sandpaper to kitchen sponges. But on this day, in 1997, Johnson wanted Hansen to test human blood for chemical contamination.
Several of 3M’s most successful products contained man-made compounds called fluorochemicals. In a spray called Scotchgard, fluorochemicals protected leather and fabric from stains. In a coating known as Scotchban, they prevented food packaging from getting soggy. In a soapy foam used by firefighters, they helped extinguish jet-fuel fires. Johnson explained to Hansen that one of the company’s fluorochemicals, PFOS — short for perfluorooctanesulfonic acid — often found its way into the bodies of 3M factory workers. Although he said that they were unharmed, he had recently hired an outside lab to measure the levels in their blood. The lab had just reported something odd, however. For the sake of comparison, it had tested blood samples from the American Red Cross, which came from the general population and should have been free of fluorochemicals. Instead, it kept finding a contaminant in the blood.
DRH note: This is the first time I’ve linked to a ProPublica story without making a critical comment. While I think their ethics on revealing people’s taxes were shoddy, as was their analytic ability, I found this piece persuasive.
With respect to the last 2 items above, as Arnold Kling would say, “Have a nice day.”
READER COMMENTS
Richard W Fulmer
Jun 23 2024 at 1:27pm
According to the CBO, the four largest sources of the $400 billion spike are:
o Changes to the student loan program – $145 billion
o Failure of the FDIC to recover payments made to resolve bank failures – $70 billion
o Additional legislation – $60 billion
o Higher than expected Medicaid costs – $50 billion
David Henderson
Jun 23 2024 at 2:25pm
Thanks, Richard. Yes, those data are in the Reason article that I linked to.
John R. Samborski
Jun 23 2024 at 5:35pm
I don’t know about Covid but I know a little about HIV and AIDS. If Peter Duesberg was certain that HIV doesn’t cause AIDS, he should have injected HIV into himself and let doctors verify that it was in his body and that he was still healthy. If he wasn’t willing to do that, then he didn’t really believe what he was saying.
steve
Jun 23 2024 at 6:31pm
It’s pretty easy to find that PEPFAR does more than make sure that people get drugs for HIV. They do wide scale testing including screening for cervical cancer. They do treatment for TB. They do pregnancy interventions to make sure mothers get drugs. (Last I looked transmission rate was about 30% with our intervention.) They do circumcisions to stop spread and also hand out condoms to stop spread.
I would regard that first paragraph as a blatant lie as it’s very easy to find out that PEPFAR does much more. (Duesberg is basically an attention seeking flat earther. No one should debate him.)
https://www.kff.org/global-health-policy/fact-sheet/the-u-s-presidents-emergency-plan-for-aids-relief-pepfar/
Steve
David Henderson
Jun 23 2024 at 11:35pm
Thanks, steve.
What do you think of his disagreement with the idea that PEPFAR has saved 25 million lives?
steve
Jun 24 2024 at 2:04pm
I spent a bit fo time looking around and cant find the methodology used by the PEPFAR people claiming 25 million lives saved. You can do some very rough back of the envelope stuff without seeing their numbers. Untreated HIV usually advances to AIDs in about 10 years. Untreated AIDS is death in 1-3 years. The program has been in effect for about 20 years let’s say they saved half of the 20 million treated. (Remember that a lot of these numbers are first world generated and poor countries have worse supportive care.) If you want to count ahead and include lives that will be saved then you get 20 million. Current life expectancy for a treated person with HIV is about 70.
With untreated HIV about 30% of babies will have the virus, but treated its 1% or less with current drugs, but lets say 2% since much of that time they would have used older drugs. Most of the people in poor country with HIV are of fertile age and have fairly high birth rates so lets guess 20 million babies. Untreated you get 6 million HIV babies vs treated you get 400,000. So you save about 5 million kids so we are up to 15 million.
They claim to have done over 70 million HIV tests. One presumes some people who find out they are positive take precautions but I dont know the percentage. They have handed out almost 2 million doses of PrEP and millions of condoms. Then, if memory serves they have done about 50 million circumcisons which cuts risk of HIV transmissions by about half (and other STD.) Then there are the cervical cancer screenings.
These numbers are rough and I would need to do more digging to find up to date numbers rather than relying on memory so much. The numbers for that last group are especially unclear to me. That said my best guess is that it might be a bit less than 25 million, people do tend to exaggerate their successes, but it’s plausible and even if off probably within a few million.
Steve
David Henderson
Jun 24 2024 at 3:33pm
Thanks, steve.
Henri Hein
Jun 24 2024 at 1:31pm
I followed the link, and here is the statement on HHS’s page:
To me that would read as if HHS is claiming the HIV/AIDS response only was responsible for saving the 25 million lives.
steve
Jun 24 2024 at 3:33pm
You could go to the PEPFAR site continue reading and see what they claim as their response to HIV/AIDS. They clearly believe that stuff like cervical cancer screening is part of that effort and that it goes well beyond handing out drugs.
Steve
David Henderson
Jun 24 2024 at 3:34pm
Thanks, Henri.
Comments are closed.