Learning Fiscal Discipline: Colorado’s Success, Shortcomings, and Regulatory Ruse
Excerpt:
At its core, TABOR codifies limits on both taxation and spending. It has been so successful that, for the fourth straight year, the State of Colorado announced that they would be refunding taxpayers, this time to the tune of $1.7 billion.
TABOR is not, however, a panacea to government overreach. While TABOR limits how much Colorado taxes and spends, it does not limit the state regulatory code, which has grown uninhibited. Defenders of a free society must take a multi-pronged approach to limiting government.
by David Hebert and Thomas Savidge, The Daily Economy, December 17, 2024.
DRH comment: I’ve talked to an economist friend in Colorado who tells me of some of the problems with TABOR, even as a way of limiting taxes and spending. But it’s much better than what we have in California at the state level.
How to Get Rid of a Tenured Professor
by Roger Pielke, Jr., The Honest Broker, December 16, 2024.
Excerpts:
The resolution — reproduced above — also demanded that, “faculty, students, staff, and administrators [unite] into a powerful cohort that advocates for and takes significant action toward reducing GHG emissions – across the campus, community, state, and nation.”
The entire campus was to engage in political advocacy,
“[We are] urging policy makers, including the regents, system administrators, and campus leadership, to implement swift and systemic changes in order to avoid the worst impacts of extreme weather events, the devastation of human habitats, the collapse of ecosystems, and the loss of biodiversity.”
This reads more like a mission statement for Greenpeace than it does anything remotely related to the mission of a flagship state university.
And:
In 2022, in response to faculty demands, the university hosted a climate advocacy conference – the Right Here, Right Now Climate Summit. This “summit” emphasized celebrities (below), activists, and plenty of exhortations to political action. There was no obvious connection to the university’s actual mission.
And:
A decision was made that all eight graduate courses that I had developed and taught as part of the graduate certificate program were no longer to be offered — This meant that all of the classes I had been recruited to Colorado to develop and teach were no longer being offered.8
I requested of the ENVS chair that I take complete responsibility for leading the continuation of the science policy center (I even found an external partner) and that I would again oversee the S&T graduate certificate program — but he told me no, absolutely not, he would not allow me to do that.
First ask what it means
by David Friedman, David Friedman’s Substack, December 13, 2024.
It [a living wage] sounds as though it means something — a wage sufficient to live on. That ought to mean a wage below which you would die but that is not how the term is usually used.
Someone reasonably ingenious and energetic living in a warm climate might be able to keep himself alive with no income at all, given the existence of food banks, dinners for the poor, and other sources of free food; some homeless people probably do. Even for someone without those advantages, enough income to stay alive is much less than people who use the term imagine. The estimate of economic historians is that the average real income of the world was about one twentieth of the current US average through most of history, which means that a sizable fraction of all the people who ever lived did it on the equivalent of less than two thousand dollars a year. Of course, even if someone on that income could stay alive in the modern US, his life would probably be shorter than the lives most modern Americans live.
As were the lives of most people in the past.
If we are looking for an objective definition and abandon the idea of taking the term literally as enough income not to die of hunger or exposure, it is tempting to interpret it as enough so that your life expectancy is not reduced by your low income. That, however, is more than the US average income, since there are multiple ways in which additional income could increase life expectancy, even if only slightly, beyond the income most of us live on. A chauffeur expert in safe driving and the safest car money could buy. A week every year in an elite medical facility being tested for everything that could possibly go wrong.
What people actually mean by a living wage, as best I can tell, is a wage at which they can imagine themselves living a tolerable life. That varies a lot depending both on one’s standard of tolerable and how wide a range of alternatives one considers, whether it includes lentils instead of meat, sharing a single room with four roommates, buying only used clothing.
DRH comment: When I was strapped for funds in my late teens and early 20s, I sometimes bought clothing at Goodwill. I no longer need to. But a few years ago, I couldn’t find a heavy jacket to wear in 40-degree-plus weather, even though I was willing to pay up to $200. So I went to Goodwill and found one I liked–for $8.
How Many Americans Really Want Mass Deportation?
by Fiona Hartigan, Reason, December 17, 2024.
Excerpt:
But a new survey suggests that Americans’ support for mass deportation comes with important—and overlooked—caveats. Sixty percent of Republicans believe that “immigration enforcement should prioritize violent criminals and those with final orders of removal rather than ‘all individuals without legal status,'” per a survey from the Bullfinch Group and the National Immigration Forum. Three-quarters of Republicans agreed that “family unity, respect for human dignity, and protection for the persecuted” must be “key priorities” as the government ramps up border security and immigration enforcement.
Overall, “significant majorities of groups” that voted for Trump “want his administration to focus immigration enforcement on threats to public safety rather than cast an unlimited net,” the National Immigration Forum observed. The survey was conducted earlier this month among 1,200 adults, including 1,000 registered voters, and found similarly high support for that idea among Democrats, independents, liberals, and moderates.
Hidden Scars: How COVID Lockdowns Altered Teen Brains Forever
by James Goodman, SciTechDaily, December 19, 2024.
Excerpt:
A recent study reported the somewhat alarming findings that the social disruptions of COVID-19 lockdowns caused significant changes in teenagers’ brains.
Researchers at the University of Washington in Seattle used MRI scans to examine the adolescent brain’s cortex — the folded outer layer responsible for complex thinking. They discovered that the typical age-related thinning of the cortex accelerated after the lockdowns, with girls showing more pronounced changes than boys.
Woman’s right leg amputated after waiting 8 days for bed at Winnipeg’s HSC to treat open wound
by Ian Froese, CBC News, December 16, 2024.
Excerpt:
A Manitoba woman had her right leg amputated after complications following a knee replacement surgery two months earlier.
Roseanne Milburn, 61, went ahead with the scheduled amputation last Friday, after weeks of complications stemming from a post-surgery infection.
In late November, a surgeon at Winnipeg’s Health Sciences Centre began removing dead tissue from her right knee, with the intention of stitching her up later that day after she was seen by an orthopedic surgeon at Concordia Hospital.
She was sent to Concordia, but couldn’t be transferred back to HSC because there wasn’t a bed available for the specialist to finish the procedure. Instead, she spent eight days languishing at Concordia with a painful open wound.
Once she finally got to HSC, Milburn went under the knife for another infection, but due to the long delay in stitching up the wound, she said she was told her leg wasn’t salvageable.
READER COMMENTS
steve
Dec 22 2024 at 10:47am
The amputation thing doesnt make any sense. From the Concordia hospital site.
“Our main surgical specialty is orthopedics which includes hip and knee replacements as well as upper extremity orthopaedics such as shoulder replacements. Each year, more than 1,600 total and partial hip and knee replacements and over 300 upper extremity procedures are done at Concordia. We also do general surgery and endoscopy procedures. Many of these procedures are conducted on a day surgery basis, while others require a longer-term stay on one of our surgical units.”
Treating post-op infections is part of doing total joints. Any hospital that specializes in joint surgery would have the ability to take care of post-op infections. There is no such thing as a specialist in closing wounds. There has to be more to the story.
Steve
Craig
Dec 22 2024 at 11:49am
“At its core, TABOR codifies limits on both taxation and spending. ”
I feel the word ‘codify’ here is a bit misleading inasmuch as the word tends to suggest statutory limits on taxing/spending. Indeed that tends to be the problem with such things as the debt ceiling at the federal level which theoretically restricts the growth of debt but which is routinely raised, indeed every statutory limit to hold back spending seems to fail. TABOR is a constitutional restriction on government authority.
“In framing a government which is to be administered by men over men, the great difficulty lies in this: you must first enable the government to control the governed; and the next place, oblige it to control itself.” – Madison / Federalist 51
And that’s why something like TABOR should show the way forward because statutory limits have been tried and have failed and at this point the delegated authority needs to be taken away because the federal government has proven that they simply cannot be trusted with such authority.
Craig
Dec 22 2024 at 11:57am
Switzerland employs a constitutional provision that is broadly similar called the ‘debt brake’ https://www.efd.admin.ch/en/the-debt-brake
Ahmed Fares
Dec 23 2024 at 1:48am
We Canadians love our healthcare system, warts and all. We know because Canadians told us so.
From another site:
Also, this:
source: Canada Is The World’s Best Country For Free Or Universal Healthcare; WHO
robc
Dec 23 2024 at 9:48am
I have been in CO for over 3 years now.
TABOR is constantly under attack. The state legislature tries to undermine it whenever they can (but especially so in non-election years, they backed off this year). Every year there are ballot questions to make exceptions.
For example, a new tobacco tax was bringing in more revenue than expected, so there was a ballot question (this was from 2023) to allow the state to keep that extra money instead of sending it back to the retailers. It passed.
There was a similar one this year, I think related to a firearms tax, that also passed.
It is part of the older libertarianish bent of Colorado. Both TABOR and the charter schools are very popular and can’t be touched (out-right) despite the majority legislature hating both.
robc
Dec 23 2024 at 10:00am
Adding on to above, for clarification purposes, the 2024 TABOR rebate (when I file my taxes in a few months) will be two-fold this year:
First, a reduction of state tax rate from 4.4% to 4.25%.
Second, a cash rebate of $554.
The first is across the board for everyone, the second is a “sales tax” rebate and depends on your income level. It varies from $117 (single, AGI under 53k) to $1130 (married filing jointly, AGI over $302k).
Mine is for married, AGI between $105k and $166k. Because of the step nature of the rebate, if you are very, very close to a step up, it can make sense to lie about your income and add in some false “other income”. In general, I would prefer if the entire rebate came in the form of tax rate reduction. Or, if they really want part of it to be a “sales tax” rebate, reduced the state sales tax for the next year by an appropriate amount.
robc
Dec 23 2024 at 10:04am
More details, if anyone cares, the TABOR rebate brackets this year:
Adjusted gross income ranges
Single filer
Joint filer
Incomes up to $53,000
$177
$354
$53,001 to $105,000
$240
$480
$105,001 to $166,000
$277
$554
$166,001 to $233,000
$323
$646
$233,001 to $302,000
$350
$700
$302,001 and up
$565
$1,130
David Henderson
Dec 25 2024 at 2:42pm
Thanks, robc.
Comments are closed.