Migrants prepared for the Darién crossing in Necoclí, shopping for tents, flashlights and water-purification pills. The passage through the Darién requires hiking along muddy paths in dense, roadless jungle for a couple of days or more, with little access to fresh water or defense against mosquitoes.
The cost of a trek like the one Mr. Huang was attempting ranges from $7,000 to $10,000 to pay for smugglers, transportation and lodging, Chinese migrants say. The going rate for more direct or safer smuggling routes, such as air passage to Mexico where snakehead “agents” bribe customs officials to let Chinese in with forged travel documents, is $60,000 or more, the migrants say.
This is from Wenxin Fan and Shen Lu, “Fleeing China, Many Take Dangerous Route to U.S.,” Wall Street Journal, April 16 (April 17 print edition.) The news item is a page 1 story and it’s good old-fashioned WSJ reporting. I would love to quote almost every paragraph.
These Chinese people are seeking asylum in the United States, and a large percent of them get it, but to get to the southern border, they need to take huge risks. The biggest challenge is crossing the Darien Gap.
Imagine how much better things would be, for them and for us U.S. taxpayers, if the U.S. government made it easy for Chinese people to come here and claim asylum and in return charged, say, $30,000 to go towards reducing the federal deficit. There would be tens of thousands of takers, fewer lives lost, and productive people coming due to the selection bias of paying $30,000.
Do they come here to work? I would bet almost all of them do, given the age at which they come. But they are also seeking liberty. Remember when many Americans welcomed people who fled from authoritarian and totalitarian governments?
READER COMMENTS
nobody.really
Apr 21 2023 at 9:05am
We still do–sometimes.
Fazal Majid
Apr 21 2023 at 9:09am
Well, China would respond the way Fidel Castro did, by freeing criminals (not political prisoners) and sending them off to burden the US. Starving people smugglers or income by offering a safe and legal alternative would be a great improvement, still.
The Chinese are exceptionally hard-working and entrepreneurial people, so I would expect ordinary Chinese refugees to be assets to wherever they seek refuge, certainly Australia’s benefited despite its harsh policies.
The UK is granting Hong Kong residents a UK sort-of-passport and path to citizenship, one of the few smart policies they’ve implemented in the last decade or so.
Jon Murphy
Apr 21 2023 at 1:45pm
If the CCP is paying $30k (or whatever the price is) per prisoner, it’s not clear how much of a net burden they would be.
Jose Pablo
Apr 22 2023 at 2:41pm
by freeing criminals (not political prisoners) and sending them off to burden the US
There are between 70 and 100 million Americans with a criminarl record (even a US ex-President could join this group too in the future).
https://www.sentencingproject.org/app/uploads/2022/08/Americans-with-Criminal-Records-Poverty-and-Opportunity-Profile.pdf
I think that no matter how many criminals the Chinese send to us, they would be greatly diluted among the vast amount of native colleagues
Thomas Hutcheson
Apr 21 2023 at 11:36pm
Why not a $10,000 signing bonus? 🙂 We’ll still make it back on income tax over a few years.
Jose Pablo
Apr 22 2023 at 3:35pm
The marginal “cost” of letting in an additional chinesse is very likely even more negative than the figure you point out …
… but, the pricing scheme should be aimed at extracting as much “consumer surplus” as possible. I would go even further than David for wealthy Chinese. The government can always flight them in in First Class as part of the Premium Package
Mactoul
Apr 21 2023 at 11:43pm
Is liberty only to be found in US?
There are Indian asylum seekers as well and India is supposed to be largest democracy ever.
Jose Pablo
Apr 22 2023 at 2:45pm
largest democracy
This “largest” makes reference to the amount of people living in India. It is not intended to say anything about the “quality” of Indian democracy.
Democracies come in differents sizes and colors: Russia is a democracy, Venezuela is a democracy, Turkey is a democracy, California is a democracy …
What can I say …
Comments are closed.