(An aside: when describing the above, regular, non-emigrant citizens in the US never have the slightest familiarity with what I’m talking about. These indignities are instantly familiar to even the fanciest of us developed-world middle-class immigrants, but a perpetual surprise to citizens. If they have that little insight, you’ll probably grok why they can’t understand a Honduran lad with three socks and one shoe who’s running from a civil war.)
This is from James Heathers, “I Quit,” Medium, June 20. HT2 Tyler Cowen.
You won’t understand that paragraph without understanding the previous few paragraphs. So here they are:
Being an immigrant (‘ex-pat’ is stupid, I was a very indifferent ‘pat’ to begin with) will knock a few dents in this, though. Even if you’re a fancy Australian person, one of the ‘good’ immigrants (typing that concept makes me throw up in my mouth, but the attitude is real), the process has a few brickbats waiting for you.
Let me make that concrete: when we moved to the US, we bought flights, flew the cat (it isn’t cheap), and then immediately had to pay four months rent up front for an apartment at a weird time outside the rental cycle (first and last month, broker’s fee, security deposit). With the unfortunate exchange rate, that was all the money I had.
All of it.
And that was immediately followed by seven months of sitting around, because my PhD hadn’t been marked yet, unable to start a postdoctoral fellowship I had already been awarded, because I didn’t have a PhD yet, technically.
I filled the time with something useful, of course. I worked on research, I read, I went to the gym, but I couldn’t even do odd jobs — it was illegal. I had a similar experience waiting for my work visa to get filed.
Then, later, my wife wore the same hat getting a work permit authorized through the visa I had for my second postdoc, waiting months for university administration to issue her with spousal status, so she could work. At a job someone really wanted to give her.
Now, recently, waiting for work authorization that comes in advance of my green card has been the same story.
This is the abridged version, leaving out four separate visa renewal trips out of the country and a good deal else that I won’t bore you with.
Suffice to say, we have lost ~36 months worth of salary since 2014 waiting for someone else to fill out or file a form.
Heather’s experience immigrating to the United States was worse than mine, but I immediately grokked it because mine was pretty bad.
By the way, that’s not the main point of his article. His article is worth reading for more reasons than the details of his immigration experience, especially his predictions about where academia is going for the next few years.
The bottom line from that discussion: Man, did I ever time my leaving academia well.
READER COMMENTS
Megen de la Mer
Jun 25 2020 at 7:27pm
Ho hum – another millenial whinging about a trivial first world problem.
Your readers might be unaware that Heathers received his education gratis from the Australian taxpayer. Under Australia’s higher education policy, Australians repay the cost of their university education through income contingent loans. This excellent scheme only requires you to commence repaying (at a modest rate) when your Australian income reaches a certain level (and payments are suspended if your income falls below that level and resume only if your income increases back to the trigger income level). Expats avoid any repayment and therefore receive a free university education.
Ironically, many expats return to Australia to retire (not surprisingly, as the majority of our large migration intake nominate life style as their primary reason for migrating) and then access the health system as aged clients.
robc
Jun 26 2020 at 7:53am
I can suggest two easy fixes to the problem you point out:
Privatize higher education
Privatize health care
Wasnt that easy?
Megen de la Mer
Jun 26 2020 at 10:55pm
Hmm – do you mean we should address questions of moral hazard by copying US systems?
How’s that going at the moment?
AMT
Jun 25 2020 at 7:59pm
Maybe he shouldn’t have actually moved until his work authorization had finished processing. It sounds like it would have at least saved 14 (7×2) of those 36 months…
Mactoul
Jun 26 2020 at 2:04am
As a postdoc myself two decade ago in foreign countries, I sympathize. Postdocs typically lose a lot of time in such formalities. It has not much to do with immigration though but with the peculiarities of university system. I myself waited many months for my doctoral degree to come through but in my own country.
Dylan
Jun 26 2020 at 7:05am
Not taking away from the immigration difficulties, which I wish were easier, but I am curious about how he talks about the 4 months of rent and plane tickets taking all of his savings, and then not being able to make any money for the next 7 months, but still somehow being able to survive? How did that work out?
IronSig
Jun 26 2020 at 6:49pm
I bookmarked the Medium piece and tagged it with “Immigration” and “Kludgocracy.”
JK Brown
Jun 26 2020 at 8:10pm
Just the other night I listened to Bret Weinstein lay out in graphic manner the grant, grad student, PhD racket used by universities to keep their cash coming in. Fake shortages of science students to keep the visas and foreign students coming in.
mbka
Jun 28 2020 at 10:15pm
I can totally relate to this. I went through much of the same type of BS as a postdoc in the US in the 90’s. Endless job insecurity, forced inactivity, and financial losses, all due to endless, stultifying paperwork and year-long delays. After 5 years of trying to just live normally, I gave up and moved to Singapore. The US just wasn’t worth the grief.
That was 20 years ago. I am still in Singapore. Oh yes, I am a white STEM PhD from a rich Western country. And I shudder at what the US immigration must be like for non white non rich non hyper-educated people. Actually I don’t have to shudder, I know. Because I have friends. But from the above comments, unless someone has gone through that kind of experience, they don’t get it.
Comments are closed.